Skip to content

Best Early Modern Fantasy Books (1930's to 1950's)

Best Fantasy Between 1930 to 1959

See the ranking

After the development of Fantasy in the early part of the 20th century, it truly seemed like the genre was moving towards a golden age. Then the real world became a priority.

Most of the 40’s were taken up by World War 2 and the ensuing aftermath. The 50’s saw the rise of communism and the start of the cold war.

But the entertainment was phenomenal! 

On screen, we had James Dean, Humphrey Boggart, Marilyn Monroe, Elizabeth Taylor, Charlton Hest. On radio and filling concert halls you had Elvis, Chuck Berry, Frank Sinatra. It was a time of contrasts. Capitalism and Communism. War and Peace. Jazz and Rock and Roll.

The upshot of all of this is that Fantasy as a genre was submerged and interspersed with Gothic horror, science fiction, and religion. A rebirth and renaissance of fantasy fiction with new ideas, new genres, and a wealth of fiction that forever influenced the fantasy genre as a whole. 

Some memorable works came out of this mix: C.S. Lewis and The Narnia Chronicles and I am Legend by Richard Matheson.

The torch of True Fantasy was, however, carried by only 2 authors: Tolkien, whose The hobbit and Lord of the Rings molded the genre into what we know today, and Poul Anderson who wrote the Broken Sword and, according to some, is one of the lost great fantasy authors.

Here is our list of the 25 Best Early Modern Fantasy. 

By "early modern' we mean fantasy written in 1930's to 1950's -- a thirty year period that saw some of the biggest conflict the world had ever seen (WW2) and remarkably, along with the suffering and tragedy of the war, saw some of the world's greatest fantasy put to pen in the form of Tolkien's Hobbit and Lord of the Rings. 

But Tolkien is not the only great work to come from this period -- Lewis, Anderson, and many more authors started birthing classic fantasy tales, giving definite form and shape to modern fantasy.

The list displays a good indication of how fantasy contributed to the development of both science fiction as well as horror novels. It also highlights the immeasurable contributions made to the genre by Tolkien, Anderson, and Lewis. This list covers 30 years and wide variety of genres and subgenres. 

All these differences are united by one thing: each book contributed to fantasy in some significant way.

These books forever changed the face of fantasy -- and in some cases, started the modern idea of what fantasy is. If authors like Tolkien lite the fantasy torch, generations of authors since have picked up the torch and carried it to new heights. These are NOT given by date of publication, but rather our personal curation for quality of story, impact on the genre, and critical acclaim.

Read this list for some of the best fantasy history can offer.

The ranking

1
Lord Of The Rings

Lord Of The Rings

by Tolkien, J.r.r.

Buy on Amazon About this book

2
The Chronicles Of Narnia

The Chronicles Of Narnia

by Lewis, C. S.

A classic high fantasy series with much adventure to offer. But, it can also be read allegorical and incorporates Christian imagery.

Buy on Amazon About this book

3
The Broken Sword

The Broken Sword

by Anderson, Poul

Buy on Amazon About this book

4
I Am Legend

I Am Legend

by Matheson, Richard

One of the first to make vampirism or zombies have a scientific origin with plenty of medical inquiry and rational causation provided.

Buy on Amazon About this book

6
The Iron Castle

The Iron Castle

by Donald, Angus

Buy on Amazon About this book

7
The Borrowers

The Borrowers

by Norton, Mary

Buy on Amazon About this book

8
Dandelion Wine

Dandelion Wine

by Bradbury, Ray

The first in a series of stories about Green Town, this is the story of one summer in a young boy's life—a magical summer where he discovers is how aliveness.

Buy on Amazon About this book

9
Conjure Wife

Conjure Wife

by Leiber, Fritz

What if every woman secretly practised witchcraft? A professor discovers his wife's charms, in Leiber's classic of suburban magic.

Buy on Amazon About this book

10
The 13 Clocks

The 13 Clocks

by Thurber, James

Buy on Amazon About this book

13
The Screwtape Letters

The Screwtape Letters

by Lewis, C. S.

Letters from a senior devil to his nephew on how to corrupt a human soul, C. S. Lewis's sharp satire.

Buy on Amazon About this book

14
Islandia

Islandia

by Wright, Austin Tappan

Buy on Amazon About this book

15
Stuart Little

Stuart Little

by White, E. B.

Buy on Amazon About this book

18
The Hobbit

The Hobbit (The Lord Of The Rings) Start here

by Tolkien, J.r.r.

Smaug is the classic dragon figure lying under the mountain—a scary creature who keeps the dwarves from their home and who must be defeated.

Buy on Amazon About this book

19
At The Mountains Of Madness

At The Mountains Of Madness

by Lovecraft, H. P.

An Antarctic expedition finds the ruins of an ancient civilisation, and something that is still alive, a Lovecraft landmark.

Buy on Amazon About this book

20
Lost Horizon: A Novel

Lost Horizon: A Novel

by Hilton, James

A popular success, this novel has philosophical and social commentary and idealized the lost world as a paradise.

Buy on Amazon About this book

21
The Sword In The Stone

The Sword In The Stone (The Once And Future King) Start here

by White, T. H.

A bit of King Arthur and Merlin for children. This book adds a bit of education and a bit of humor to the ancient legends. 5. Mary Norton, The Borrowers. An imaginative story about a teeny tiny family living under the floorboards.

Buy on Amazon About this book

The shortlist

Want the next list like this in your inbox? New releases and the lists readers are opening most, by email.